. Karen Methods for Diagnosis Genetic Screening- Benefits to Individual: Treatment
or ability to plan based on genetic status Factors that influence ability to Diagnose and Treat
based on Genetic Tests Overview of Genetic Testing: Penetrance in
suceptibility to cancer When a genetic disease is the result of a interaction
among genes, often the first mutation is not enough to cause
the disease but makes the cell vulnerable if an
environmentally induced mutation occurs. The cell may be
able to repair DNA damage resulting from an original
mutation until the repair mechanisms are also damaged or the
cell is otherwise overwhelmed. It make take multiple
mutations to fully activate a malignancy. Complexity of BRCA1, BRCA2, Fanconi Interaction
Source: http://www.biocarta.com/pathfiles/h_atrbrcaPathway.asp#history General Description of BRCA/Fanconi Interaction: When a
cell's DNA is damaged - whether by excessive sunlight,
chemicals such as those found in cigarette smoke, radiation,
or other means - five of the Fanconi genes team up to
produce a protein "complex" that stimulates a sixth gene.
That gene, dubbed D2, orders production of a protein that
moves near BRCA1, whose job is to help repair damaged
DNA. If BRCA1 or its partner in DNA repair, BRCA2, are
defective or aren't switched on properly, DNA damage can
accumulate in cells, increasing their chances of
malfunctioning and becoming cancerous. This complexity of interaction, as well as hundreds of
variations of the BRCA1 gene, make the diagnosis and
prognosis for carriers of BRCA1 uncertain at the current
time . This complexity explains the penetrance of BRCA1
being only 60-85%. Issues with Genetic Screening for Diagnosis and
Treatment: 2. Privacy and Confidentiality. Discrimination
by employer or insurance or family/friends. 3. Freedom of Choice. Pressures to be tested,
know results and make reproduction choices, by individual
and family members. 4. Health Care Costs. Cost of testing and
treatment, but also cost of NOT testing if the public is
funding health care costs. Case Examples: Would you take the genetic test and
what would you do with the results? References: U.S. Department of Human and Health Services, Access
Excellance Research Center, "Understanding Gene Testing",
http://www.accessexcellence.org/AE/AEPC/NIH/ Nuffield Council on Bioethics 2001, "Genetic Testing",
http://www.nuffieldbioethics.org/publications/geneticscreening/rep0000000062.asp GeneReviews, BRCA1 and BRCA2 Hereditary Breast/Ovarian
Cancer, http://www.geneclinics.org/profiles/brca1/index.html,
last update 3/4/2000 Cancer Genetics Web, http://www.cancerindex.org/geneweb/BRCA1.htm ..

1. Informed Decision Making. Adequate
counseling before testing, to interpret test results and
choose options for treatment or other actions.
Updated 3/25/03 by thatcher@sonoma.edu