Math 150

Projects

A Proof of the Pythagorean Theorem

Steve Wilson

 

It is possible to prove that the Cartesian coordinate plane is a Euclidean plane with practically no axioms. We define a point to be an ordered pair of real numbers, and the plane to be the set of all ordered pairs of real numbers. This enables us to use what we know about real numbers. The axioms are the axioms for the development of the real number system.

 

An important definition is the distance between two points.

 

Definition: Let  (x1, y1)  and  (x2, y2)  be two points. The distance between them is

 

 

What we are doing with this definition is we are actually assuming the Pythagorean Theorem, which is well known to be equivalent to Euclid’s Parallel Postulate. However, we are not assuming the whole Pythagorean Theorem, just the special case where the perpendicular sides of the triangle are horizontal and vertical. It is possible to prove the entire Pythagorean Theorem from this special case.

 

Let  ABC be a right triangle with right angle at  C. 

 

 

 

If we let  A = (x1, y1),  B = (x2, y2),  and  C = (x3, y3),  then to say that C is the right angle is to say that the slopes of  AC  and  BC  are negative reciprocals of each other.

 

 

 

Note that If either if these denominators is  0, then the lines are horizontal or vertical, and we have dealt with that case with the definition of distance, so we do not have to worry about zero denominators.

 

Cross multiply.

 

(y1y3)(y2y3)  =  -(x1x3)(x2x3)

 

Transpose to get rid of the negative

 

(y1y3)(y2y3)  +  (x1x3)(x2x3)  =  0

 

Remove parentheses

 

y1y2y1y3y2y3 + y32 + x1x2x1x3x2x3 + x32  =  0

 

Transpose all the terms that do not involve  x3  or  y3  to the other side of the equation.

y1y3y2y3 + y32x1x3x2x3 + x32  =  - y1y2 - x1x2

Double both sides.

– 2y1y3 – 2y2y3 + 2y32 – 2x1x3 – 2x2x3 + 2x32  =  - 2y1y2 - 2x1x2

Add  x12 + x22 + y12 + y22  to both sides and split up the  2x32  and  2y32.

x12 – 2x1x3 + x32 + y12 – 2y1y3 + y32 + x22 – 2x2x3 + x32 + y22 - 2y2y3 +y32 = x12 – 2x1x2 + x22 + y12 – 2y1y2 + y22

(x1x3)2 + (y1y3)2 + (x2x3)2 + (y2y3)2 = (x1x2)2 + (y1y2)2

a2                  +                 b2                   =                   c2

This proves that if the triangle is a right triangle, the sides are related by the Pythagorean Theorem. For the converse, simply reverse the steps. This direction is actually more straightforward than the way we did it above. The things that we had to pull out of the air to put into both sides of the equation will automatically cancel out. Where we multiplied the binomials in the fourth step to remove the parentheses, we will need to factor when we reverse our steps, and that may require a bit of cleverness, but the steps are reversible, and we have the implication both ways. If it is a right triangle, then  a2 + b2 = c2, and if  a2 + b2 = c2,  then the triangle is a right triangle.